Alternative business structures and their impact on owner pay
As your business grows, it may be in your best interest to transition to a different business structure since each offers different tax benefits and liability protection.
(How you pay yourself will change depending on your business entity.)
For instance, with:
- A Single-Member LLC: You can still take an owner’s draw. However, LLCs offer limited liability protection. You may also elect S Corp taxation to reduce self-employment tax.
- An S Corporation: Owners receive a reasonable salary through payroll and can take additional profit distributions that receive a lower tax rate.
- A Multi-Member LLC or Partnership: Owners take distributions based on their ownership percentage, and file their taxes accordingly.
- A Sole Proprietorship: You take an owner’s draw, and the IRS considers all income as personal income.
Here’s a more in-depth chart that breaks down these options and more:

Electing S Corp status can help minimize self-employment tax for sole proprietors earning a high income.
However, this requires additional administrative work, such as payroll and filing corporate tax returns. To determine the best structure for your situation, consult with a tax professional and consider which legal tools can streamline the transition.
Head to the next section if you’d like to take our quiz on choosing a business entity.
Quiz: Which business structure is right for you?
Take the following quiz to see which business structure might best fit your goals as you scale.
(Final results are at the end of the quiz!)
Question 1: How much control do you want over your business decisions?
A) I want to make all decisions myself without consulting others.
B) I’m okay with sharing decision-making power with others if needed.
What it means for your structure:
A) Sole Proprietorship or Single-Member LLC (SMLLC) might be your best bet since you’ll have complete control.
B) A multi-member LLC or partnership could work if you share your decision-making with others.
Question 2: How do you feel about personal liability for business debts?
A) I’m comfortable being personally responsible for business debts and legal issues.
B) I’d prefer to limit my liability and protect my assets.
What it means for your structure:
A) Sole Proprietorship offers no liability protection. Meaning you’re personally responsible for business debts.
B) LLCs and S Corporations provide limited liability protection. They can shield personal assets from business-related debts.
Question 3: How would you like to pay yourself?
A) I’m okay with taking profits as distributions (not salary).
B) I want a regular salary with clear tax withholding.
What it means for your structure:
A) For Single-Member LLCs or Multi-Member LLCs taxed as a partnership, you can take profits as distributions. These are taxed based on your share of the LLC’s income.
For LLCs taxed as S Corps, owners must take a reasonable salary through payroll (with tax withholding). They can take profits as distributions.
B) If you want to pay yourself a salary and reduce your self-employment tax burden, S Corporation status could be ideal. It allows salary payments in addition to distributions.

Question 4: How much administrative work are you willing to take on?
A) I prefer minimal administrative work and a more straightforward structure.
B) I’m willing to do additional paperwork for tax benefits and liability protection.
What it means for your structure:
A) Sole Proprietorships or Single-Member LLCs are the simplest structures, requiring minimal paperwork.
B) LLCs and S Corporations involve more paperwork — but offer benefits like limited liability and tax flexibility.
Question 5: What is your expected income level?
A) I expect my business income to be lower and don’t need tax-saving strategies.
B) I anticipate higher business income and want strategies to reduce taxes.
What it means for your structure:
A) A Sole Proprietorship or Single-Member LLC might be sufficient if you’re just starting and expect a lower income.
B) If your income grows, an S Corporation might be worth considering to reduce self-employment taxes. As an S Corp, you can pay yourself a reasonable salary and take additional profits as distributions (taxed at a lower rate).
Question 6: How do you feel about paying taxes?
A) I’m comfortable paying taxes based on my business income without overplanning.
B) I want to minimize my tax liability and plan ahead.
What it means for your structure:
A) Sole Proprietorships and Single-Member LLCs are taxed as personal income. Meaning you’ll pay self-employment taxes on all profits.
B) S Corporations allow you to pay yourself a salary and take distributions, which can help you save on self-employment taxes.
Quiz results
Mostly A’s: You might be best suited for a Sole Proprietorship or a Single-Member LLC. These structures offer simplicity and ease of control. (But don’t provide personal liability protection.)
Mostly B’s: Consider an LLC or S Corporation. These structures offer liability protection and tax flexibility — with an S Corporation providing a salary option to reduce self-employment taxes.
Friendly reminder: Consult a tax professional before choosing your business entity.
Wrap up
Paying yourself as a sole proprietor requires careful planning.
Separating your personal finances from the business finances, monitoring cash flow, and saving for taxes are essential for financial success.
Whether you continue operating as a sole proprietor or transition to an LLC or S Corp, structuring your payments promotes financial stability and supports long-term business growth.
Remember, Billdu is here for you! Sign up for a free 30-day free trial to see how much simpler financial management can be.